2017 EMF Supercross series - Protest thread

Moderators: nioubie, M@xTizZz, Wahlamt

User avatar
M@xTizZz
Posts: 2032
Joined: Wed Jan 25, 2012 4:20 pm
Team: TizZy-Design
Location: France

2017 EMF Supercross series - Protest thread

Postby M@xTizZz » Sun Jan 15, 2017 4:23 am

Image
Protest thread




ↂ Demos
Round 1 - Anaheim I - Pro - Amateur
Round 2 - San Diego - Pro - Amateur
Round 3 - Anaheim II - Pro - Amateur
Round 4 - Phoenix - Pro - Amateur
Round 5 - Oakland - Pro - Amateur
Round 6 - Arlington - Pro - Amateur
Round 7 - Minneapolis - Pro - Amateur
Round 8 - Atlanta - Pro - Amateur
Round 9 - Toronto - Pro - Amateur
Round 10 - Daytona - Pro - Amateur
Round 11 - Indianapolis - Pro - Amateur
Round 12 - Detroit - Pro - Amateur
Round 13 - St Louis - Pro - Amateur
Round 14 - Seattle - Pro - Amateur
Round 15 - Salt Lake City - Pro - Amateur
Round 16 - East Rutherford - Pro - Amateur
Round 17 - Las Vegas - Pro - Amateur


ↂ Rules
You can check the rulebook here
Special rule for warnings :
"3 warnings will result of one week suspension."
"If you don't have any warning for 6 rounds, your past warnings will be reset."


ↂ Penaltys general recap

Docked :
Rd1:
Alexis Leclair - #43 - 6454 - (1 position, 3rd=>4th) - cutting the track while passing someone
Rd2:
...
Rd3:
...
Rd4:
...
Rd5:
...
Rd6:
...
Rd7:
...
Rd8:
...
Rd9:
...
Rd10:
...
Rd11:
...
Rd12:
...
Rd13:
...
Rd14:
...
Rd15:
...
Rd16:
...
Rd17:
...


DQ :
Rd1:
...
Rd2:
...
Rd3:
...
Rd4:
...
Rd5:
...
Rd6:
...
Rd7:
...
Rd8:
...
Rd9:
...
Rd10:
...
Rd11:
...
Rd12:
Enzo Boutigny - #871 - 10255 - blue flag(many times)/unsafe riding/ aggressive riding
Rd13:
Victor NICOT, #5 (8423) - tyring to ruin the qualifying spot of someone during the heat
Rd14:
...
Rd15:
...
Rd16:
...
Rd17:
...


Warning :
Rd1:
Kellen Brauer - #94 - 4928 - aggressive riding
Maxime Tison - #51 - 4820 - unsafe riding
Alexis Leclair - #43 - 6454 - unsafe riding
Stephane Guido - #15 - 18324 - aggressive riding
Alex Carlo - #69 - 3950 - aggressive riding - x2 - [2nd warning]
Antoni Castellano - #155 - 9361 - aggressive riding
Andrea Di Pietro - #220 - 10421 - aggressive riding
Rd2:
Rush Chapman - #92 - 14794 - aggressive riding
Alex Carlo - #69 - 3950 - aggressive riding - [3rd warning = 1 week suspension]
Rico De Laat - #75 - 19896 - unsafe restart after crash
Connor Lynds - #1 - 17192 - unsafe track's entering
Devin Davis - #410 - 4275 - cutting the track while passing someone
Chris Channing - #40 - 17088 - aggressive riding
Alexander Lagerkvist - #411 - 11392 - unsafe track's entering
Andreas Bergstrom - #175 - 10895 - aggressive riding
Niklas Pingel - #150 - 12776 - unsafe riding
Enzo Boutigny - #871 - 10255 - trolling on qualifying server
Rd3:
Edward Mora - #42 - 11742 - unsafe track's entering
Aurelien Van de Kapelle - #534 - 10633 - blue flag
Florent Lambillon - #61 - 16438 - blue flag
Rush Chapman - #92 - 14794 - unsafe riding - [2nd warning]
Jake Rose - #77 - 16679 - harsh language
Rush Chapman - #92 - 14794 - aggressive riding - [3rd warning = 1 week suspension]
Rico De Laat - #75 - 19896 - cutting the track while passing someone - [2nd warning]
Victor Nicot - #5 - 8423 - harsh language
Logan Toucheque - #557 - 16487 - aggressive riding
Logan Toucheque - #557 - 16487 - cutting the track while passing someone - [2nd warning]
Enzo Boutigny - #871 - 10255 - blue flag - x2 - [3rd warning = 1 week suspension]
Beau Delobelle - #719 - 16338 - aggressive riding
Dorano Plevoets - #123 - 15793 - unsafe riding
Alexander Lagerkvist - #411 - 11392 - blue flag - [2nd warning]
Rd4:
Steven Maginot - #821 - 1224 - unsafe riding
Emeric Richard - #84 - 13039 - blue flag
Théo Cavalli - #352 - 14999 - unsafe restart after crash
Fredrik Langagergaard - #58 - 12475 - unsafe/aggressive riding
Peeters Jorn - #248 - 9810 - aggressive riding
Christophe Vander Beken - #737 - 6026 - unsafe/aggressive riding
Emilien Mabru - #522 - 2141 - aggressive riding
Rd5:
Walter Gebhardt - #251 - 12235 - aggressive riding
Fabian Goleo - #584 - 23993 - blue flag
Jake Rose - #77 - 16679 - harsh language - [2nd warning]
Florian Kane - #71 - 9118 - unsafe restart after crash
Logan Toucheque - #557 - 16487 - unsafe track's entering - [3rd warning = 1 week suspension]
Mads Balzer - #322 - 10101 - aggressive riding
Andreas Bergstrom - #175 - 10895 - aggressive riding - [2nd warning]
Joey Carter - #445 - 18347 - unsafe/aggressive riding
Rd6:
Dylan Ogilby - #48 - 17970 - aggressive riding
Rico De Laat - #75 - 19896 - unsafe restart after crash - [3rd warning = 1 week suspension]
Logan Leitzel - #95 - 19661 - aggressive riding
Sergey Kurashev - #101 - 13104 - aggressive riding
Antoni Castellano - #155 - 9361 - unsafe/aggressive riding - [2nd warning]
Mattias Andersson - #446 - 7579 - unsafe track's entering
Mattias Andersson - #446 - 7579 - aggressive riding - [2nd warning]
Rd7:
Olle Sundberg - #80 - 13088 - unsafe/aggressive riding
Dom Aggett - #114 - 23904 - aggressive riding
Corentin Julian - #74 - 2233 - aggressive riding
Corentin Julian - #74 - 2233 - cutting the track while passing someone - [2nd warning]
Corentin Mary - #112 - 19885 - aggressive riding
Quentin Vasseur - #133 - 18522 - aggressive riding
Alexander Lagerkvist - #411 - 11392 - unsafe restart after crash - [3rd warning = 1 week suspension]
Mads Balzer - #322 - 10101 - blue flag - [2nd warning]
Mads Balzer - #322 - 10101 - unsafe track's entering - [3rd warning = 1 week suspension]
Rd8:
Sergey Kurashev - #101 - 13104 - unsafe track's entering
Alex Monch - #63 - 5738 - aggressive riding
Alex Monch - #63 - 5738 - blue flag - [2nd warning]
Logan Depaty - #57 - 1915 - aggressive riding
Jordan Moxey - #28 - 18285 - unsafe track's entering
Jordan Moxey - #28 - 18285 - aggressive riding - [2nd warning]
Rd9:
Rico De Laat - #75 - 19896 - harsh language - [4th warning]
Victor Nicot - #5 - 8423 - blue flag - [2nd warning]
Victor Nicot - #5 - 8423 - unsafe riding - [3rd warning = 1 week suspension]
Alanas Saulys - #29 - 13377 - unsafe track's entering
Alanas Saulys - #29 - 13377 - unsafe track's entering - [2nd warning]
Frederick Langagergaard - #58 - 12475 - blue flag - [2nd warning]
Frederick Langagergaard - #58 - 12475 - unsafe riding - [3rd warning = 1 week suspension]
Austin Ecklund - #241 - 23267 - unsafe riding
Dale Mullins - #214 - 15496 - unsafe riding
Dale Mullins - #214 - 15496 - aggressive riding - [2nd warning]
Jesper Bye - #144 - 15659 - aggressive riding
Ryan Ashman - #140 - 16403 - unsafe riding
Ryan Ashman - #140 - 16403 - blue flag - [2nd warning]
Rd10:
Manu Da Silva - #157 - 20243 - blue flag
Harry White - #210 - 19518 - unsafe riding
Harry White - #210 - 19518 - unsafe riding - [2nd warning]
Rd11:
Jordan Moxey - #28 - 18285 - aggressive riding - [3rd warning = 1 week suspension]
Anders Nielsen - #234 - 7895 - blue flag
Anders Nielsen - #234 - 7895 - aggressive riding - [2nd warning]
Adrien Saguez - #290 - 20195 - aggressive riding
Rd12:
Enzo Boutigny - #871 - 10255 - unsafe riding - [4th warning]
Enzo Boutigny - #871 - 10255 - unsafe restart after crash - [5th warning]
Colton Mitchell - #27 - 6767 - aggressive riding
Colton Mitchell - #27 - 6767 - aggressive riding - [2nd warning]
Logan Toucheque - #557 - 16487 - unsafe track's entering - [4th warning]
Logan Toucheque - #557 - 16487 - cutting the track to pass someone - [5th warning]
Logan Toucheque - #557 - 16487 - unsafe riding - [6th warning = 2 weeks suspension]
Enzo Boutigny - #871 - 10255 - aggressive riding - [6th warning = 2 weeks suspension]
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Rd13:
Rico DE LAAT, #75 (19896) - aggressive riding - [5th warning]
Jesper BYE, #144 (15659 - harsh language - [2nd warning]
Connor HOLYAK, #154 (9655) - unsafe riding
Connor HOLYAK, #154 (9655) - made crash a leader - [2nd warning]
Connor HOLYAK, #154 (9655) - made crash a leader - [3th warning = 1 week suspension]
Walter GEBHARDT, #251 (12235) - blue flag
Walter GEBHARDT, #251 (12235) - unsafe track's entering - [2nd warning]
Walter GEBHARDT, #251 (12235) - blue flag - [3th warning = 1 week suspension]
Felix ANDERLUND, #292 (9890) - unsafe restart after crash
Dorano PLEVOETS, #123 (15793) - blue flag
Dorano PLEVOETS, #123 (15793) - unsafe riding - [2nd warning]
Manu DA SILVA, #157 (20243) - blue flag - [2nd warning]
Manu DA SILVA, #157 (20243) - unsafe riding - [3th warning = 1 week suspension]
Axel DIEU, #637 (19748) - unsafe riding
Axel DIEU, #637 (19748) - aggressive riding - [2nd warning]
Axel DIEU, #637 (19748) - unsafe restart after crash - [3th warning = 1 week suspension]
Arthur THEISEN, #201 (19888) - cutting the track
Arthur THEISEN, #201 (19888) - aggressive riding - [2nd warning]
Arthur THEISEN, #201 (19888) - unsafe restart after crash - [3th warning = 1 week suspension]
Rd14:
Dennis FJELDBERG, #6 (2472) - unsafe restart after crash
Dennis FJELDBERG, #6 (2472) - unsafe riding - [2nd warning]
Fred HEATHER, #13 (4686) - unsafe track's entering
Kevin HERGLE , #333 (22217) - unsafe track's entering
Rd15:
Dale MULLINS, #214 (15496) - unsafe riding - [3rd warning = 1 week suspension]
Jesper BYE, #144 (15659) - unsafe riding - [3rd warning = 1 week suspension]
Ryan ASHMAN, #140 (16403) - blue flag - [3rd warning = 1 week suspension]
Ryan ASHMAN, #140 (16403) - unsafe riding - [4th warning]
Ryan ASHMAN, #140 (16403) - unsafe restart after crash - [5th warning]
Lee BRADLEY, #458 (20015) - unsafe track's entering
Rd16:
...
Rd17:
...


Suspended :
Rd1:
...
Rd2:
Alex Carlo - #69 - 3950 - aggressive riding x3 - [3rd warning = 1 week suspension]
Chris Channing - #40 - 17088 - aggressive riding/track's cutting/blocking someone - [1 week suspension]
Rd3:
Jake Rose - #77 - 16679 - aggressive riding/blue flag - [1 week suspension]
Rush Chapman - #92 - 14794 - aggressive/unsafe riding x3 - [3rd warning = 1 week suspension]
Enzo Boutigny - #871 - 10255 - blue flag x2/trolling in qualifying server - [3rd warning = 1 week suspension]
Justin Wood - #218 - 9304 - sharing key - [2 weeks suspension]
Lyzander Bigwood - #370 - 11486 - sharing key - [2 weeks suspension]
Rd4:
...
Rd5:
Logan Toucheque - #557 - 16487 - unsafe track's entering/aggressive riding x2 - [3rd warning = 1 week suspension]
Rd6:
Rico De Laat - #75 - 19896 - cutting the track while passing someone/unsafe restart after crash x2 - [3rd warning = 1 week suspension]
Rd7:
Mads Balzer - #322 - 10101 - unsafe track's entering/blue flag/aggressive riding - [3rd warning = 1 week suspension]
Alexander Lagerkvist - #411 - 11392 - unsafe track's entering/blue flag/unsafe restart after crash - [3rd warning = 1 week suspension]
Rd8:
Manu Da Silva - #157 - 20243 - unsafe restart after crash/made someone else crash on purpose - [1 week suspension]
Rd6:
...
Rd7:
...
Rd8:
...
Rd9:
Victor Nicot - #5 - 8423 - blue flag /unsafe riding/ harsh language - [3rd warning = 1 week suspension]
Frederick Langagergaard - #58 - 12475 - blue flag/unsafe riding/unsafe riding - [3rd warning = 1 week suspension]
Rd10:
...
Rd11:
Jordan Moxey - #28 - 18285 - aggressive riding (x2)/unsafe track's entering - [3rd warning = 1 week suspension]
Jordan Moxey - #28 - 18285 - aggressive riding - [1 week suspension]
Rd12:
Enzo Boutigny - #871 - 10255 - blue flag(many times)/unsafe riding/ aggressive riding - [1 week suspension]
Enzo Boutigny - #871 - 10255 - unsafe riding/aggressive riding/unsafe restart after crash - [6th warning = 2 weeks suspension]
Logan Toucheque - #557 - 16487 - unsafe track's entering/cutting the track to pass someone/unsafe riding - [6th warning = 2 weeks suspension]
Rd13:
Connor HOLYAK, #154 (9655) - made crash a leader(x2) on purpose in the same race - [1 week suspension]
Connor HOLYAK, #154 (9655) - made crash a leader(x2)/unsafe riding - [3th warning = 1 week suspension]
Walter GEBHARDT, #251 (12235) - blue flag many time, unsafe track's entering, pass a leader - [1 week suspension]
Walter GEBHARDT, #251 (12235) - blue flag(x2)/unsafe track's entering - [3th warning = 1 week suspension]
Victor NICOT, #5 (8423) - trying to ruin a leader's qualifying spot during the heat - [2 weeks suspension]
Felix Anderlund #292 (9890) - tbone on purpose - [1 week suspension]
Manu DA SILVA, #157 (20243) - unsafe riding/blue flag(x2) - [3th warning = 1 week suspension]
Axel DIEU, #637 (19748) - unsafe riding/aggressive riding/unsafe restart after crash - [3th warning = 1 week suspension]
Arthur THEISEN, #201 (19888) - cutting the track/aggressive riding/unsafe restart after crash - [3th warning = 1 week suspension]
Rd14:
...
Rd15:
Dale MULLINS, #214 (15496) - unsafe riding(x2)/aggressive warning - [3rd warning = 1 week suspension]
Jesper BYE, #144 (15659) - aggressive riding/harsh language/unsafe riding - [3rd warning = 1 week suspension]
Ryan ASHMAN, #140 (16403) - unsafe riding/blue flag(x2) - [3rd warning = 1 week suspension]
Rd16:
...
Rd17:
...


----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Image
Maxime Tison #51 [EMF] | #nonumberanymore [rF]
|EMF Official admin Image| |Tizzy Design Owner Image|
Skype ID : max_tizzz

User avatar
M@xTizZz
Posts: 2032
Joined: Wed Jan 25, 2012 4:20 pm
Team: TizZy-Design
Location: France

Re: 2017 EMF Supercross series - Protest thread

Postby M@xTizZz » Sun Jan 15, 2017 6:07 am

1st POST UP TO DATE WITH RD1 protests

ↂ Round 1 recap


CLASS: SX1 Pro ; MOTO: Main event ; TIME: 21mn28
PLAINTIFF: Dennis Fjeldberg
EMF Crew's DESCRIPTION: Dennis jumped the big quad on the first rythm section, he landed on a lapper, ran 3meters and got a game's crash.
Image
VERDICT: We got the confirmation it's a bug of the game from jlv.
jlv wrote:It's a bug in the game I've never been able to fix. Not sure what the exact cause is. Something to do with extra deep collisions.

BUT we still decided to give his position back to Dennis before his game's crash (9th=>6th).


CLASS: SX1 Pro ; MOTO: Main event ; TIME: 9mn10
PLAINTIFF: Jason Sole - #49 - 19533
DEFENDANT: Kellen Brauer - #94 - 4928
PLAINTIFF's DESCRIPTION: I report Kellen for the move around 9 minutes 10 second. I don't understand the interest of this move while we have fallen already 2 times before it.
He came wide open and cut me while we were 6th and 7th. I lost 9 positions with this.
EMF Crew's DESCRIPTION: Well there are 3 actions actually on this protest.
1st action (8mn49) : race incident, Kellen is hitting the rear wheel of Marrot, he crashed and Jason can't avoid him so he crashed also.
Image
2nd action (9mn) : both riders came up from the 1st crash, we can clearly see Jason going on Kellen in the whoops section while Kellen is straight.
Image
3rd action - the (9mn10) : Kellen is raging at Jason cause he made him fall again in the whoops section, he just go wide open on Jason to punt him.
Image
VERDICT: Kellen made a mood's move. He already lost time with his first crash with Marrot. This second crash due to Jason not going straight in the whoops section made Kellen become mad...
PENALTY: Warning "aggressive riding" [Rulebook - section 2.9]


CLASS: SX1 Pro ; MOTO: Main event ; TIME: 4mn15
PLAINTIFF: EMF Crew
DEFENDANT: Maxime Tison - #51 - 4820
MAXIME's DESCRIPTION : This line 3-3-1 was maybe not the best i could use just behind an other rider, you were lagging a bit in the starting line before, and you had a little "roll back" lag when i hitted the single after the rythm.
I hitted you on air, it was not really you but your lag so i crashed before landing on you (your real "you" not your lag this time)
EMF Crew's DESCRIPTION: Maxime is hitting the big line (3-3-1) in the 1st rythm section and made fall Logan Leitzel in the next corner. He can't brake
Image
VERDICT: Hit the big line and make others crash.
PENALTY: Warning "unsafe/aggressive riding" [Rulebook - section 2.9]


CLASS: SX1 Pro ; MOTO: Main event ; TIME: 20mn40
PLAINTIFF: Hunter Root - #1 - 8752
DEFENDANT: Alexis Leclair - #43 - 6454
PLAINTIFF's DESCRIPTION:
Image
EMF Crew's DESCRIPTION: Alexis is hitting a big line (never seen before!) just behind Hunter. He tryed to pass him on the inside but cutted a bit the bales and made him fall by at the landing.
Image
Image
Image
VERDICT: Hit the big line and make others crash + cut the track
PENALTY: Warning "unsafe/aggressive riding" [Rulebook - section 2.9] + docked one position for "cutting the track while passing someone" [Rulebook - section 2.1]


CLASS: SX2 Pro ; MOTO: LCQ ; TIME: 2mn34 / 2mn43
PLAINTIFF: Gaetan Pich - #117 - 17009
DEFENDANT: Stephane Guido - #15 - 18324
PLAINTIFF's DESCRIPTION: Unsafe riding in a race (2mn34), he made crash others on purpose (2mn43)
EMF Crew's DESCRIPTION: 1st action he's doing a backflip on the wall. He didn't hit anyone but he was really not safe to do it while Gaetan was passing him.
Image
On the 2nd action, Stephane is hitting the big line on the inside of Gaetan and go for a block pass in the next corner. He hit Gaetan's front wheel and make him crash.
Image
VERDICT: Stephane is doing stupid move (backflip) + Block pass on purpose.
PENALTY: Warning "unsafe/aggressive riding" [Rulebook - section 2.9]


CLASS: SX2 Pro ; MOTO: LCQ ; TIME: Last corner
PLAINTIFF: Jarne Robyn - #728 - 5144
DEFENDANT: Alex Carlo - #69 - 3950
PLAINTIFF's DESCRIPTION: I was in 4th place the last corner and Alex Carlo crashes into me to get the final transfer spot. But we both crash and I still get 4th.
EMF Crew's DESCRIPTION: For this action, we have to keep in mind it's the last lap of the LCQ. We can see Alexis Vanbrabant crashing for 4th position, so Jarne is 3rd after that, Alex is 4th.
We can see Alex cutting the last end of the whoops section to go for the block pass on Jarne.
Image
VERDICT: T-bone on purpose.
PENALTY: Warning "aggressive riding" [Rulebook - section 2.9]


CLASS: SX2 Pro ; MOTO: Heat1 ; TIME: 1mn15
PLAINTIFF: Corentin Delaruelle - #535 - 1242
DEFENDANT: Alex Carlo - #69 - 3950
PLAINTIFF's DESCRIPTION: Alex just didn't brake and took me out.
EMF Crew's DESCRIPTION: We can see Corentin is opening the inside line really hard, Alex is going to pass him and decided to not break when he understood he was late to make the pass.
Image
VERDICT: T-bone on purpose.
PENALTY: Warning "aggressive riding" [Rulebook - section 2.9]


CLASS: SX1 Amat ; MOTO: Main event ; TIME: 15mn
PLAINTIFF: Maxime Bourut - #212 - 9248
DEFENDANT: Antoni Castellano - #155 - 9361
PLAINTIFF's DESCRIPTION: Not first time castellano blockpass like a noob.
EMF Crew's DESCRIPTION: Maxime is jumping 2-1 on the big triple while Antoni is jumping it. Antoni first hitted the break in the landing and then went on the inside to still make the pass.
Image
VERDICT: Dirty block pass on purpose.
PENALTY: Warning "aggressive riding" [Rulebook - section 2.9]


CLASS: SX1 Amat ; MOTO: Main event ; TIME: 1mn30
PLAINTIFF: Thomas Jaz - #141 - 8626
DEFENDANT: Andrea Di Pietro - #220 - 10421
PLAINTIFF's DESCRIPTION: Hello, I wanted to protest against Andrea di pietro in relation to his block pass against me at the beginning of the 2nd turn.
EMF Crew's DESCRIPTION: Andrea go for the block pass instead of taking the inside line. He could take the inside, still make the pass but without making crash Thomas.
Image
VERDICT: Dirty block pass on purpose.
PENALTY: Warning "aggressive riding" [Rulebook - section 2.9]
Maxime Tison #51 [EMF] | #nonumberanymore [rF]
|EMF Official admin Image| |Tizzy Design Owner Image|
Skype ID : max_tizzz

User avatar
Sib43
Posts: 1832
Joined: Wed May 13, 2009 7:10 pm
Team: pridemx.at
Location: Austria
Contact:

Re: 2017 EMF Supercross series - Protest thread

Postby Sib43 » Sun Jan 15, 2017 10:51 am

Why should be "blockpass on purpose" cause a warning or even ban? This is part of racing imo...
Image

Tristan.Botteram
Posts: 289
Joined: Mon Dec 29, 2014 12:28 pm
Team: TBM Design
Location: The Netherlands
Contact:

Re: 2017 EMF Supercross series - Protest thread

Postby Tristan.Botteram » Sun Jan 15, 2017 12:07 pm

Sib43 wrote:Why should be "blockpass on purpose" cause a warning or even ban? This is part of racing imo...

^^

alex521
Posts: 110
Joined: Thu Jan 15, 2015 8:50 am
Team: Kulan Visual
Location: sweden
Contact:

Re: 2017 EMF Supercross series - Protest thread

Postby alex521 » Sun Jan 15, 2017 12:23 pm

Tristan.Botteram wrote:
Sib43 wrote:Why should be "blockpass on purpose" cause a warning or even ban? This is part of racing imo...

^^

^^
Image

YzJarne_196
Posts: 615
Joined: Sat Feb 11, 2012 4:00 pm
Location: Belgium

Re: 2017 EMF Supercross series - Protest thread

Postby YzJarne_196 » Sun Jan 15, 2017 12:48 pm

Sib43 wrote:Why should be "blockpass on purpose" cause a warning or even ban? This is part of racing imo...

This. When you blockpass someone succesfully that's just racing. When you both go down it usually means it was too agressive, in this case you can give warnings or penalties. Imagine real life ama SX with emf rules, everyone would be banned by round 3 :lol:
2016 EMF Retro SX pro championship: 6th

CeeJayHDz
Posts: 565
Joined: Mon Feb 23, 2015 5:05 pm
Team: Privateer

Re: 2017 EMF Supercross series - Protest thread

Postby CeeJayHDz » Sun Jan 15, 2017 1:08 pm

M@xTizZz wrote:Image
Image
Image


These protests are getting a little pathetic now, none of these 3 even deserved a protest nevermind a warning, we cant even go near someone now without having to worry about being banned?

1st incident, completely Dennis' fault for trying to quad right behind a lapper, does not deserve a position back.

2nd incident, clean pass just got unlucky with the games collisions and went down

3rd incident, also a good pass

Both the 2nd and 3rd have time to check up and let the other through.

Grow some balls ffs.
Image

Sandhapper
Posts: 1203
Joined: Sat Jul 10, 2010 9:21 am
Team: MotoRAD
Location: The Nederlands

Re: 2017 EMF Supercross series - Protest thread

Postby Sandhapper » Sun Jan 15, 2017 1:19 pm

CeeJayHDz wrote:These protests are getting a little pathetic now, none of these 3 even deserved a protest nevermind a warning, we cant even go near someone now without having to worry about being banned?

1st incident, completely Dennis' fault for trying to quad right behind a lapper, does not deserve a position back.

2nd incident, clean pass just got unlucky with the games collisions and went down

3rd incident, also a good pass

Both the 2nd and 3rd have time to check up and let the other through.

Grow some balls ffs.

I have to agree that it's weird that people get warned / banned for block passing now. But I've nothing to say because I'm not in the EMF protest crew.

Luckly I am not in that crew though, some guys don't like my logic! :lol:
https://www.facebook.com/rkdigitalart
2013 EMF outdoors 2nd place overall
2013 MxSCentral outdoors 2nd place overall
2012 EMF outdoors 2nd overall
2012 SMA sx 2nd overall
2011 SMA outdoors champion

Image

User avatar
nioubie
Posts: 829
Joined: Fri Jun 22, 2012 1:48 pm
Team: *eMc*
Location: France
Contact:

Re: 2017 EMF Supercross series - Protest thread

Postby nioubie » Sun Jan 15, 2017 4:34 pm

Well some guys will agree, some won't anyway it's still hard to judge if a block pass is legit or not.

For me, if you block the other rider line , and the guy have "time" to brake, its of course legit. But if you put your rear whell on his front, most of the time he got no chance to avoid a crash; it's a barcia/hansen shit. Even thought it's looks legit in real life, you can't really allow it in this game, or some will abuse it. In real life you don't go down 10 times per race. And doing such a blockpass could cause you to go down and finish in the back of the pack.

i see people raging because some can't jump straight, because some make mistakes, or some are too slow or too bad.
What would they say if they got taken down every corner.

You have to remember it's a Game, and a Game is made to have fun.

Watch the yesterday heat with tomac and andersson to see what is nice and legit !
Then watch the heat with Hanssen the idiotic noob who stay 15 years on 250 and still can't ride clean.

User avatar
nioubie
Posts: 829
Joined: Fri Jun 22, 2012 1:48 pm
Team: *eMc*
Location: France
Contact:

Re: 2017 EMF Supercross series - Protest thread

Postby nioubie » Sun Jan 15, 2017 5:04 pm

CeeJayHDz wrote:
M@xTizZz wrote:


These protests are getting a little pathetic now, none of these 3 even deserved a protest nevermind a warning, we cant even go near someone now without having to worry about being banned?

1st incident, completely Dennis' fault for trying to quad right behind a lapper, does not deserve a position back.

2nd incident, clean pass just got unlucky with the games collisions and went down

3rd incident, also a good pass

Both the 2nd and 3rd have time to check up and let the other through.

Grow some balls ffs.


If you read the protest carefully, we give Dennis position back because it was last lap, and his game crashed completely, not just his bike.

2nd incident is not clean, theres no way the other guy could avoid collision.

3rd pretty same , if he could avoid it, i guess he would have. do you really think he said : "ho someone will cut my line i will still try to pass, pray and gaz !"

I dont think so. but maybe u could teach us with your big experience uid 17k . :)

Ddavis
Posts: 15532
Joined: Wed Sep 28, 2011 1:02 am
Team: DX3
Location: CA
Contact:

Re: 2017 EMF Supercross series - Protest thread

Postby Ddavis » Sun Jan 15, 2017 7:42 pm

All of the penalties seem fair with the passes/actions that were made. I agree block passes are part of racing, but almost every example provided above is a dirty punt/takeout.
Screw the haters, I just love moto.
Image

User avatar
Osari52
Posts: 1098
Joined: Tue Jan 24, 2012 11:44 pm
Team: Vitamin Water / SYS
Location: San Diego, CA
Contact:

Re: 2017 EMF Supercross series - Protest thread

Postby Osari52 » Mon Jan 16, 2017 5:20 pm

I'll take the "warning" but I'll tell you guys this: If you are out there and cross-jumping all over the place after having FIVE DAYS to learn the track, then I have no problem with putting you on the ground to move you out of my way. Jason was so hell bent on keeping me behind him that he turned left in the whoops. Seriously EMF goof-balls, learn how to race in this game instead of riding like Vince Friese into every turn. I have already let Jason know I'm not going to race him like others now.

Image
Kellen Brauer | Freelance Moto Journalist | Co-Creator of Start Your Systems
Image Image Image

User avatar
kxalex31
Posts: 1066
Joined: Fri Mar 23, 2012 2:35 pm
Team: Evergood
Location: Louisiana
Contact:

Re: 2017 EMF Supercross series - Protest thread

Postby kxalex31 » Mon Jan 16, 2017 7:18 pm

M@xTizZz wrote:CLASS: SX2 Pro ; MOTO: LCQ ; TIME: Last corner
PLAINTIFF: Jarne Robyn - #728 - 5144
DEFENDANT: Alex Carlo - #69 - 3950
PLAINTIFF's DESCRIPTION: I was in 4th place the last corner and Alex Carlo crashes into me to get the final transfer spot. But we both crash and I still get 4th.
EMF Crew's DESCRIPTION: For this action, we have to keep in mind it's the last lap of the LCQ. We can see Alexis Vanbrabant crashing for 4th position, so Jarne is 3rd after that, Alex is 4th.
We can see Alex cutting the last end of the whoops section to go for the block pass on Jarne.
Image
VERDICT: Block pass on purpose.
PENALTY: Warning "aggressive riding" [Rulebook - section 2.9]


I don't see how this is even worthy of a protest. I took him out for the last transfer on the last corner of the last lap. Plus its not like he still didn't get the transfer spot.
Image

User avatar
nioubie
Posts: 829
Joined: Fri Jun 22, 2012 1:48 pm
Team: *eMc*
Location: France
Contact:

Re: 2017 EMF Supercross series - Protest thread

Postby nioubie » Mon Jan 16, 2017 7:54 pm

kxalex31 wrote:
M@xTizZz wrote:CLASS: SX2 Pro ; MOTO: LCQ ; TIME: Last corner
PLAINTIFF: Jarne Robyn - #728 - 5144
DEFENDANT: Alex Carlo - #69 - 3950
PLAINTIFF's DESCRIPTION: I was in 4th place the last corner and Alex Carlo crashes into me to get the final transfer spot. But we both crash and I still get 4th.
EMF Crew's DESCRIPTION: For this action, we have to keep in mind it's the last lap of the LCQ. We can see Alexis Vanbrabant crashing for 4th position, so Jarne is 3rd after that, Alex is 4th.
We can see Alex cutting the last end of the whoops section to go for the block pass on Jarne.
Image
VERDICT: Block pass on purpose.
PENALTY: Warning "aggressive riding" [Rulebook - section 2.9]


I don't see how this is even worthy of a protest. I took him out for the last transfer on the last corner of the last lap. Plus its not like he still didn't get the transfer spot.


in real you would be almost dead , hope u dont ride IRL ! :)

User avatar
skyzen
Posts: 229
Joined: Wed Jan 23, 2013 11:35 pm
Team: IZI Racing

Re: 2017 EMF Supercross series - Protest thread

Postby skyzen » Mon Jan 16, 2017 10:29 pm

M@xTizZz wrote:1st POST UP TO DATE WITH RD1 protests

ↂ Round 1 recap


CLASS: SX1 Pro ; MOTO: Main event ; TIME: 20mn40
PLAINTIFF: Hunter Root - #1 - 8752
DEFENDANT: Alexis Leclair - #43 - 6454
PLAINTIFF's DESCRIPTION:
Image
EMF Crew's DESCRIPTION: Alexis is hitting a big line (never seen before!) just behind Hunter. He tryed to pass him on the inside but cutted a bit the bales and made him fall by at the landing.
Image
Image
Image
VERDICT: Hit the big line and make others crash + cut the track
PENALTY: Warning "unsafe/aggressive riding" [Rulebook - section 2.9] + docked one position for "cutting the track while passing someone" [Rulebook - section 2.1]




Mad cause blok passed like a boss haha

EZ
Image

1st 2014 Motosport Outdoor Nationals
1st PanicRev Holeshot Artist of the Year Award
1st TMFR Australian Sx / Holeshot King
1st 2013 MXS Of Nations FRANCE / Individual


Return to “EMF Racing”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest