2010 MX Track Competition - Voting

[ddmx]

Void that last

Alabama MX by Dearnhardtfan7 - 9
Aldmoor by DJ_Diehl#777 - 7
AMA National: Millville 2008 by Checkerz448 & DJ - 2
AMA Pro National: MX 338 by Voutare - 3
Badlands by Staydown - 8
Bartows Hill MX by FactoryBr21 - 5
Green Valley MX by yFMX - 1
Hillbrook Raceway by yzmxer608 - 6
Sierra MX by PINNEDTOWIN - 4

[Sweendoggy]

Alabama MX by Dearnhardtfan7 - 6
Aldmoor by DJ_Diehl#777 - 8
AMA National: Millville 2008 by Checkerz448 & DJ - 2
AMA Pro National: MX 338 by Voutare - 4
Badlands by Staydown - 5
Bartows Hill MX by FactoryBr21 - 9
Green Valley MX by yFMX - 1
Hillbrook Raceway by yzmxer608 - 7
Sierra MX by PINNEDTOWIN - 3

[Vellu]

Alabama MX by Dearnhardtfan7 - 7
Aldmoor by DJ_Diehl#777 - 8
AMA National: Millville 2008 by Checkerz448 & DJ - 3
AMA Pro National: MX 338 by Voutare - 1
Badlands by Staydown - 6
Bartows Hill MX by FactoryBr21 - 4
Green Valley MX by yFMX - 2
Hillbrook Raceway by yzmxer608 - 9
Sierra MX by PINNEDTOWIN - 5

I enjoyed all the tracks, but as I had to put them in order this is it.

[Scummy]

Alabama MX by Dearnhardtfan7 -1
Aldmoor by DJ_Diehl#777 -7
AMA National: Millville 2008 by Checkerz448 & DJ -2
AMA Pro National: MX 338 by Voutare -8
Badlands by Staydown -3
Bartows Hill MX by FactoryBr21 -4
Green Valley MX by yFMX -5
Hillbrook Raceway by yzmxer608 -9
Sierra MX by PINNEDTOWIN - 6

[ShackAttack12]

I'd like to formally thank everybody who put forth an effort to release a track for this competition. Track comps keep this community alive by providing great tracks to ride on. I know for sure how much work and effort it takes to produce such quality pieces of work. So hats off to all of you, and THANK YOU!

Alabama MX by Dearnhardtfan7 - 7
Great ideas, its just that the scale is way too big for my liking. I prefer tracks where throttle control is key, and where you are not tapping out the bike. Visually it was ok.

Aldmoor by DJ_Diehl#777 - 8
Visually, it was great. The displacement map coupled with the traction just killed it for me. The layout felt too much like MX777 to me, up down up down up down, with big jumps.
The traction map did not suit the terrain, in my opinion. I'd love to see a realistic style track out of you, because i know you have the talent to make something sick.

AMA National: Millville 2008 by Checkerz448 & DJ - 3
Great track. Visually great and really fun displacement map. As a replica, i felt it was probably about as accurate as you guys could have created it.The whoops section really provides a great realistic experience.
I was turned off a tiny bit about some of the braking bumps, some are fricken humongous, but others are good.

AMA Pro National: MX 338 by Voutare - 4
Visually: good. Displacement map: about as accurate as you could have created it. Traction: I would have liked more of a sandy feel with a bit more drag.

Badlands by Staydown - 5
Visually: stunning. So much attention to detail all over the entire displacement map. As far as object placement and a themed track, i think this sets the bar for the future.
Displacement: Scale is a bit large for my liking. If the track was more realistic with more braking sections and more throttle control, i think you might have went top 3 by my ratings.

Bartows Hill MX by FactoryBr21 - 9
I felt that the object placement was sub par, and overall i felt that the track was released unfinished.
Displacement map was ok, i like the style of bumpiness, however not many jumps and it didn't feel like a real track to me.

Green Valley MX by yFMX - 2
Visually: Perfect. This track sets the visual standards for the future. The attention to detail is amazing. Excellent work with the shading and object placement.
Displacement map: Absolutely amazing. It feels like a fast realistic track. Ruts are so crisp and sharp, yet so rideable. A blast to race online. Only gripe is that
there wasn't much variation in line choices going through the sections.

Hillbrook Raceway by yzmxer608 - 6
Visually: OK. Objects were sub par, placement was ok. Textures were ok. Could have better shading to accent some of the bumps better.
Displacement: Great. Very fun, good variety, and a realistic feel to it. I love the sections where you have to slow up or else you'll flatland from 50ft up.

Sierra MX by PINNEDTOWIN - 1
Visually: Near perfect. Textures were great and really fit the setting of the track. Shading was done very well. Object placement was great.
Displacement map: Great. Tons of variety, great ideas, nothing unrealistic, nothing repetitive, lots of EVEN line choices, and lots to keep a rider busy.
Braking bumps and the track roughness was great, nothing over the top, but enough to keep a rider on the tips of his fingers.

[Servatis]

Alabama MX by Dearnhardtfan7 - 9
Aldmoor by DJ_Diehl#777 - 8
AMA National: Millville 2008 by Checkerz448 & DJ - 3
AMA Pro National: MX 338 by Voutare - 2
Badlands by Staydown - 5
Bartows Hill MX by FactoryBr21 - 7
Green Valley MX by yFMX - 1
Hillbrook Raceway by yzmxer608 - 6
Sierra MX by PINNEDTOWIN - 4

[MiNi]

Alabama MX by Dearnhardtfan7 - 8
Aldmoor by DJ_Diehl#777 - 9
AMA National: Millville 2008 by Checkerz448 & DJ - 2
AMA Pro National: MX 338 by Voutare - 3
Badlands by Staydown - 5
Bartows Hill MX by FactoryBr21 - 7
Green Valley MX by yFMX - 1
Hillbrook Raceway by yzmxer608 - 6
Sierra MX by PINNEDTOWIN - 4

[sam-brinkley]

Alabama MX by Dearnhardtfan7 - 8
Aldmoor by DJ_Diehl#777 - 5
AMA National: Millville 2008 by Checkerz448 & DJ - 6
AMA Pro National: MX 338 by Voutare - 7
Badlands by Staydown - 4
Bartows Hill MX by FactoryBr21 - 3
Green Valley MX by yFMX - 9
Hillbrook Raceway by yzmxer608 - 5
Sierra MX by PINNEDTOWIN - 6

[sam-brinkley]

delete my above topic lolz

Alabama MX by Dearnhardtfan7 - 3
Aldmoor by DJ_Diehl#777 - 4
AMA National: Millville 2008 by Checkerz448 & DJ - 6
AMA Pro National: MX 338 by Voutare - 7
Badlands by Staydown - 8
Bartows Hill MX by FactoryBr21 - 9
Green Valley MX by yFMX - 1
Hillbrook Raceway by yzmxer608 - 5
Sierra MX by PINNEDTOWIN - 2

[DJD]

Alabama MX by Dearnhardtfan7 - 8
I think the disp could have been more creative and little bit less wide open. I cant think of any tracks where you can be 5th gear wide open multiple times in one lap. Scale it down a bit, add some braking bumps, lay down some more textures, and i think it would be much better.

Aldmoor by DJ_Diehl#777 - 9
I F*cked up the textures and tilemap. Like I seem to always do...

AMA National: Millville 2008 by Checkerz448 & DJ - 2
Disp map is great, and the bumps are spot on. It's rough but still enjoyable. Missed a few spots with the textures, the grass underneath the track shows in some places.

AMA Pro National: MX 338 by Voutare - 3
One of my favorite tracks to race, the disp flows well, and allows for fun battles. I wish the tilemap was more "sandy" though.

Badlands by Staydown - 5
Environment is sweet, but probably my least favorite displacement map. Jumps are awkward and huge. Reminds me of Alabama MX, being wide open everywhere.

Bartows Hill MX by FactoryBr21 -6
Roughness is great, all the bumps feel very realistic. Some of the ruts could be better, and the track could use more jumps.

Green Valley MX by yFMX - 1
What can i say that already hasn't been said? Looks fantastic, rides great, fun to race. The only complaint i have is that some of the ruts are hard to see, mostly on the whoop section going up hill.

Hillbrook Raceway by yzmxer608 - 7
Another solid track, nothing amazing, but the disp was enjoyable.

Sierra MX by PINNEDTOWIN - 4
This track kicks my ass, i don't think I've ever made a lap without falling. The environment/textures are solid, nothing amazing but they suit the track well. Ruts could be better, and the tilemap seems very slippery to me.

[tyskorn]

Void my last post.

Alabama MX by Dearnhardtfan7 - 2
Aldmoor by DJ_Diehl#777 - 7
AMA National: Millville 2008 by Checkerz448 & DJ - 3
AMA Pro National: MX 338 by Voutare - 6
Badlands by Staydown - 8
Bartows Hill MX by FactoryBr21 - 9
Green Valley MX by yFMX - 1
Hillbrook Raceway by yzmxer608 - 5
Sierra MX by PINNEDTOWIN - 4

[lluks252]

Alabama MX by Dearnhardtfan7 - 6
Aldmoor by DJ_Diehl#777 - 7
AMA National: Millville 2008 by Checkerz448 & DJ - 4
AMA Pro National: MX 338 by Voutare - 3
Badlands by Staydown - 5
Bartows Hill MX by FactoryBr21 - 9
Green Valley MX by yFMX - 1
Hillbrook Raceway by yzmxer608 - 8
Sierra MX by PINNEDTOWIN - 2

[Motoboss]

Alabama MX by Dearnhardtfan7 -7
Aldmoor by DJ_Diehl#777 - 4
AMA National: Millville 2008 by Checkerz448 & DJ -3
AMA Pro National: MX 338 by Voutare -2
Badlands by Staydown -8
Bartows Hill MX by FactoryBr21 -6
Green Valley MX by yFMX -5
Hillbrook Raceway by yzmxer608 -7
Sierra MX by PINNEDTOWIN - 1

[FMXIAN]

Alabama MX by Dearnhardtfan7 -9
Aldmoor by DJ_Diehl#777 -5
AMA National: Millville 2008 by Checkerz448 & DJ -2
AMA Pro National: MX 338 by Voutare -1
Badlands by Staydown -6
Bartows Hill MX by FactoryBr21 -7
Green Valley MX by yFMX -3
Hillbrook Raceway by yzmxer608 -8
Sierra MX by PINNEDTOWIN -4

[MotoRockstar777]

Alabama MX by Dearnhardtfan7 - 9
Aldmoor by DJ_Diehl#777 - 6
AMA National: Millville 2008 by Checkerz448 & DJ - 3
AMA Pro National: MX 338 by Voutare - 4
Badlands by Staydown - 5
Bartows Hill MX by FactoryBr21 - 7
Green Valley MX by yFMX - 2
Hillbrook Raceway by yzmxer608 - 8
Sierra MX by PINNEDTOWIN - 1