Page 1 of 1

Sweet Revenge - Beta my first track.

Posted: Wed Apr 22, 2009 5:21 am
by Phathry25
http://www.megaupload.com/?d=LNVL1JS4

My first attempt at a track. I like the practice track theme here, I'm not sure how well I've pulled it off. I'm trying like hell to avoid modeling anything for this track so I'm just trying to get by with whats out there. I'd say it's about 3/4's done, unless someone comes up with an earth shattering idea to make it better, lol. Lemme know what you think, and be honest, you know I would be. :)

Image

Image

Re: Sweet Revenge - Beta my first track.

Posted: Wed Apr 22, 2009 6:43 am
by Mittocs
Would you happened to be watching Family guy when you named this track? :wink: downloading right now

Edit: I really enjoy this track, its fun and simple. VERY good for a first track. I think you need to get started on some more!

Re: Sweet Revenge - Beta my first track.

Posted: Wed Apr 22, 2009 1:30 pm
by Garasaki
No pics eh?

Re: Sweet Revenge - Beta my first track.

Posted: Wed Apr 22, 2009 3:19 pm
by Turbine951
Wow Phathry, for a first track this is really good. All the sections had multiple options and the whoops keep you on your toes. You could add some objects and stuff but as you mentioned, its meant to have that practice track theme. As mittocs said its fun and simple and it makes me want to keep spinning laps. Hope to see this one finished soon, and also more tracks from you down the road.

The only problem was the mini map was from saint jones?

Re: Sweet Revenge - Beta my first track.

Posted: Wed Apr 22, 2009 3:26 pm
by Phathry25
OK, I have pictures now Garasaki. I started from the St.Jones folder, I haven't gotten to the finishing touches yet, my bad. And I'm just a huge Family Guy fan, so all my beta's will be named Quahog somethingorother until I put some thought into the name, lol.

Re: Sweet Revenge - Beta my first track.

Posted: Wed Apr 22, 2009 4:16 pm
by Garasaki
Oh wow I think it looks great. Construction of the elements looks pretty top notch.

(Consider that I haven't ridden the track when I made these comments)

Simply looking at the layout, 3 things jump out at me:

There's a lot of leftover space on the map

All the 90 degree corners look exactly the same

The straight count goes like this: 8 total straights. 1 is whoops. 1 is finish line double. 1 is a triple. 1 is a short dead straight (where the start turns in). AND, all 4 of these sections are consecutive. So although one person who already has ridden the track (I haven't) mentioned there are multiple lines thru each part, I suspect that at least half of the track is entirely 1 lined.

I think there is a lot of potential with this track. It appears you have jump construction pretty well down. I think if you really spend some time working on the layout you could have a really top notch track here.

I would suggest - spreading out the 1 lined (I call them "dead") straights, perhaps working in "setup" obsticals on the triple, whoops, and/or finish line double, developing a "marquee" obstical - something unique that will make the track stand out and keep riders looking forward to hitting it every lap, and I'm personally a big fan of using as much of the map as possible.

Re: Sweet Revenge - Beta my first track.

Posted: Wed Apr 22, 2009 4:35 pm
by FactoryBR21
Hey dude , im just about donwload this track and i'll be back with a pretty good coments about your track because i really apreciati guys that spend hours on tracks till get it good for realese , its looking great at pictures...

I'll edit with a review

Re: Sweet Revenge - Beta my first track.

Posted: Wed Apr 22, 2009 6:52 pm
by Wilson
Anything else from saint jones?

Re: Sweet Revenge - Beta my first track.

Posted: Wed Apr 22, 2009 11:00 pm
by Turbine951
Garasaki wrote: So although one person who already has ridden the track (I haven't) mentioned there are multiple lines thru each part, I suspect that at least half of the track is entirely 1 lined.
While I do see what you are saying about the triple, finish line, and the short straight, the actual rhythm sections do have multiple options. You can step on-step-on single through the first section, or you can triple over the table and double out to the single. The next section after the 4 little rollers you can double-double over the tabletop to the single or triple onto the table and stepoff. I'm simply saying there are choices in the rhythm sections.

Re: Sweet Revenge - Beta my first track.

Posted: Thu Apr 23, 2009 1:28 am
by wheels1758
I think this track is very fun. Each section individually is simple, but it is difficult to run a perfect lap. So far i have run a 33-something.

Re: Sweet Revenge - Beta my first track.

Posted: Thu Apr 23, 2009 2:18 am
by Voutare
Very fun, and good. You have your disp down pat. No problems at all with it. The only things that could use upgrading are the layouts.

Re: Sweet Revenge - Beta my first track.

Posted: Thu Apr 23, 2009 4:26 am
by Phathry25
Garasaki wrote:It appears you have jump construction pretty well down.
Actually it's wilson that has the jump construction figured out. He let me borrow his jumps while I master other things first. So thanks to Wilson for the nice jumps, I just changed them a lil here and there to suit my needs. :)

Re: Sweet Revenge - Beta my first track.

Posted: Thu Apr 23, 2009 9:58 am
by yomo
Ok heres what i think.

Firstly for a first track this is pretty good.

There are many good things about this track but there is not much point saying them all.

Here is what i think needs work on.
1. In my opinion the whoops are too easy.
2. Some of the jumps are 15 foot high. Apposed to the regulation 6 foot high triple jumps in real life.
3. I'm not a fan of having collisions with the bales. But that is up to you whether you think it adds to the realism or not.
4. The last timing gate just gives you enough room to make the jump (for time trial). Maybe put that back a few meters? But it is fine where it is
5. The off track textures look to "perfect" with the way they are tiled. Set the tiling pattern to random orientation.
Other than that i think this is a good track.

Hope it helped