2011 SX Series by MotoOption Rd 11 - Thursday Night Mar 17

Organize races and post results here
Post Reply
wheels1758
Posts: 4132
Joined: Tue Oct 21, 2008 5:20 pm
Location: Washington, USA
Contact:

Re: 2011 SX Series by MotoOption Rd 11 - Thursday Night Mar 17

Post by wheels1758 »

Alright...hope you're ready. On the order of one Mr.ShackAttack12 vs. Mr.Kwic :

Shack, he said he's sorry, and I think you need to go take a look at the demo again. I was not there last night, but I did take the time to watch and analyze the incident in question. Here is my take.

This is the first jump of the rhythm section after Shack passed KWIC. As you can see, there are about 1.5 - 2 bike lengths between the two riders.

Image

They both triple onto the tabletop, KWIC has gained a little on Shack.

Image

The last jump of the section, KWIC has carried a little more speed, but is still back.

Image

Different view of above jump. As you can see, Shack has started to turn in, closing off KWIC's line.

Image

This is where Shack landed, at the base of the berm.

Image

Same angle as above picture, this time at the moment KWIC is landing.

Image

As you can probably guess, KWIC had no chance of stopping before he "blatenly punted" Shack. We shall now take a look at the entire section from above.
If you trace the line that Shack took, there is no doubt it carried over into KWIC's line. As they are taking off from the last single, into the corner, KWIC has very few options:
1. Take and immediate right turn and fly over the berm, maybe missing shack.
2. Turn down into the corner and try to stay on the inside.

As you can imagine, every racer on these forums would choose option 2. Who in their right mind is going to fly off track so that someone else can take their preferred line? And for Shack to say he was Chad Reed'ed in that turn, he'd have to go take a look at the video of Reed's pass. KWIC collided with Shack in the middle of the turn, not the exit.

Image

So, in my opinion, this incident was bound to happen and would most likely happen to anyone really. I know if you are the one getting knocked around, it will seem like the guy did it out of anger or rage, but I don't believe that is the case. I also don't think you, Shack, should tell a guy to go watch the demo, when you obviously have not analyzed it OBJECTIVELY!


NOW: Shackattack12, I'd like to show you a couple things and possibly open your eyes into some ways to go faster and avoid the carnage that so often seems to find you(coincidence?).

This is the first rhythm section on the first lap. Shack was taken out in the first turn by a rider that clipped the back wheel of another and lost control...not much you can do there. But riding like you're all alone on your private track is not okay during a supercross main event. In this image, the surrounding riders are there at the time the first image was taken, they have been removed from the rest for clarity. As you can see though, there are riders around you. I'm sure you will argue that you turned in slightly in the middle to avoid a fallen rider (Jonesy). That is understandable, and if you would have been landed on there, theres not much you can do. But nearing the end of the section, you begin to turn down rapidly, eventually exiting the section at around 30 degrees from center. You did this so you could get the hot line through that next corner. This is all good when youre alone on the track. But when there are people around you, you can't do it! Of all the times you raged about people not holding a line, you yourself have some trouble as well, apparently.

Image

And for the final image. There are downed riders in the corner after the first(on the first lap) supercross triple. Again this is on the initial lap of the race. As we can see, you grab the brakes and hug the inside to avoid some downed riders. In this image, the honda rider was left in for a few frames to show how things can go wrong when you don't hold a line. You didn't actually collide, because he grabbed a handful and jumped over you. Watching the demo, you slip going off the face of the first jump and careen across the track out of control. But even before that, look at your line. you are a solid 35-40 degrees from the direction of the section. If you (1) are that far from center, you will most likely slide when you grab the throttle. and (2) are going slow around the corner, you should just roll the first jump and continue through the section. If you had gone single, step on, step off, single, you would have lost way less time that you really did. But you decided to go for a little bigger line, and look how it payed off. Even though there was no carnage here, you can clearly see that something could have happened. Imagine if someone else took that line in front of you. I can imagine you would not have been happy about it. So I really think you need to start backing it down, and the races will start to go a little more your way. It is ridiculous to hear a guy complaining about sketchy riders and lappers, when they are riding out there like the track belongs to them. Your riding style really reminds me of James Stewart. The dude is fast, but gets caught up in too much carnage because he is not about to back it down.

Image

I have been caught up in some crashes with you in the past and yes, some of them were my fault. I realize I am a mediocre rider and you probably consider me sketchy. Problem is, a lot of times that we have gotten together it is because one of us cuts down a turn, as if to shut the other one off. If you're going to ride like that, you have to be ready to take some hits, and you have to accept the fact that everyone out there is going for it. Heck, if you know a guy is coming in hot, go wide...square it up...and watch him head straight over the berm. You are faster than most everyone on here, and you have the ability to pass people. If its going to be close, shut down and pass them in the next turn. I seem to remember someone saying that about the Chad Reed/James Stewart incident.

Can someone get me some fire retardent? I think I'm going to need it!
Mikey
Posts: 7018
Joined: Sat Nov 08, 2008 1:27 am
Location: Melbourne
Contact:

Re: 2011 SX Series by MotoOption Rd 11 - Thursday Night Mar 17

Post by Mikey »

that looks so sweet! didnt read a word but looks so awesome :D
My photography work
www.mikeowenphotographer.com
wheels1758
Posts: 4132
Joined: Tue Oct 21, 2008 5:20 pm
Location: Washington, USA
Contact:

Re: 2011 SX Series by MotoOption Rd 11 - Thursday Night Mar 17

Post by wheels1758 »

O yea, I forgot to add, sorry Shack that you could only SALVAGE a fifth. Must be heartbreaking when you're leading the series by 52 points :roll:
Mikey
Posts: 7018
Joined: Sat Nov 08, 2008 1:27 am
Location: Melbourne
Contact:

Re: 2011 SX Series by MotoOption Rd 11 - Thursday Night Mar 17

Post by Mikey »

ok so i just read it, kind of interesting point of view there.
My photography work
www.mikeowenphotographer.com
ddmx
Posts: 5381
Joined: Sun Apr 20, 2008 3:36 pm
Location: Midland MI

Re: 2011 SX Series by MotoOption Rd 11 - Thursday Night Mar 17

Post by ddmx »

With 5 wins in 11 races, and a commanding 52 point lead over second in the series, you'd think life would be good in the shackattack camp, but nope. No one likes losing, and likewise, no one likes sore losers, or sore winners for that fact.

On a more light note however, when you're the best at something, and you have the spotlight on you, it's easy to become the guy that everyone critiques.
wheels1758
Posts: 4132
Joined: Tue Oct 21, 2008 5:20 pm
Location: Washington, USA
Contact:

Re: 2011 SX Series by MotoOption Rd 11 - Thursday Night Mar 17

Post by wheels1758 »

ddmx wrote:it's easy to become the guy that everyone critiques.
True. But in all honesty, I would not have said a word if he didn't come on here and call out kwic.
Juan357
Posts: 647
Joined: Tue Apr 14, 2009 9:17 pm
Location: Brasil , Rio de Janeiro

Re: 2011 SX Series by MotoOption Rd 11 - Thursday Night Mar 17

Post by Juan357 »

one thing i know.. yfmx fucked my race on 2 time , he crashed me too on atlanta "start" , me and jack.. and when he crashed me on start automatically i loose the race , why everyone is good on that track , and barry leading all the time... i think yfmx is crazy.
Track Comp 2010 Champion!
DJD
Posts: 2757
Joined: Thu Oct 02, 2008 12:56 am

Re: 2011 SX Series by MotoOption Rd 11 - Thursday Night Mar 17

Post by DJD »

Uh, i may have over-read something...but anyway.

Shack passed that kid clean, then the kid takes him out in the next corner.
wheels1758 wrote:KWIC had no chance of stopping
Your kidding right? Kwic had 20 ft on the downside after stepping off the table. Kwic could have easily slowed down

after stepping off the table, and got back into his line. Avoiding a collision. But he went for the T-bone instead.

Which is cool i guess, but what goes around comes around.
MXJProductions
Posts: 3880
Joined: Fri Feb 05, 2010 1:26 pm
Team: MXJP
Location: Bushnell, Florida.

Re: 2011 SX Series by MotoOption Rd 11 - Thursday Night Mar 17

Post by MXJProductions »

Juan I like u man, but seriously, I do not think yann just ssaid imma ruin my race as well by starting a pileup. Its the holeshot and a game where unless u are in 3rd person it is hard to see beside you ( like in real life ). Stop blaming him, and everyone else for a bad race, hell I'd give anything just to be as fast as you and race a main event, yet I see u, and others ( shack ) bitching about 5th, and 9 th place. Chill out and just be stoked u even made the main, next time u can qualify and ill ride for u, I would love the honor of making a main...

Quick EDIT: sorry djd but the pics and demo does not lie buddy, I really hope your kidding otherwise you might wanna go to the eye doctor. Just saying lol
Juan357
Posts: 647
Joined: Tue Apr 14, 2009 9:17 pm
Location: Brasil , Rio de Janeiro

Re: 2011 SX Series by MotoOption Rd 11 - Thursday Night Mar 17

Post by Juan357 »

this is true DJ , kwic taked out shack.. dirty move..

people learn how to start using brakes and riding straight please?
Track Comp 2010 Champion!
wheels1758
Posts: 4132
Joined: Tue Oct 21, 2008 5:20 pm
Location: Washington, USA
Contact:

Re: 2011 SX Series by MotoOption Rd 11 - Thursday Night Mar 17

Post by wheels1758 »

DJD wrote:Uh, i may have over-read something...but anyway.

Shack passed that kid clean, then the kid takes him out in the next corner.
wheels1758 wrote:KWIC had no chance of stopping
Your kidding right? Kwic had 20 ft on the downside after stepping off the table.
1. You are taking that out of context. That statement was made about where Kwic landed. If you look, he landed in nearly the same spot shack landed. From the point he landed, he had no chance to stop.

2. If you are Kwic, and you are following a guy in a section, are you honestly going to check up because he cuts into your line and let the guy go? I don't think so. Plus, look at where Kwic is when shack starts to cut into his line. If shack started to cut over before the last jump of the section, Kwic would have had time to react. Thing is, Shack turned on the single out and frankly, Kwic wasn't THAT far behind at that point, and didn't have a 20 foot landing to stop on.
MXJProductions
Posts: 3880
Joined: Fri Feb 05, 2010 1:26 pm
Team: MXJP
Location: Bushnell, Florida.

Re: 2011 SX Series by MotoOption Rd 11 - Thursday Night Mar 17

Post by MXJProductions »

DJD wrote:Uh, i may have over-read something...but anyway.

Shack passed that kid clean, then the kid takes him out in the next corner.
wheels1758 wrote:KWIC had no chance of stopping
Your kidding right? Kwic had 20 ft on the downside after stepping off the table. Kwic could have easily slowed down

after stepping off the table, and got back into his line. Avoiding a collision. But he went for the T-bone instead.

Which is cool i guess, but what goes around comes around.
This was in almost the same fashio of the stewart/ reed collision, difference is shack cut over, and stewart didn't. But you are completely going against everything u said about the stewie/ reed deal.

"Re: 2011 AMA Supercross Discussion

by DJD » Mon Feb 28, 2011 7:11 pm

When Stewart hit the apex of that bowl corner he could see Reed coming, instead of checking up, Stewart pins it WFO and just hits Reed.

If Stewart was smart, he would have checked up, let Reed by, then passed him in the same spot he did last lap. Situation avoided"
Brina927
Posts: 2729
Joined: Mon Jun 29, 2009 5:55 am
Team: Whipstyle
Location: Phoenix Arizona
Contact:

Re: 2011 SX Series by MotoOption Rd 11 - Thursday Night Mar 17

Post by Brina927 »

Interesting job on the "court case" Wheels. Juan/DJ I think you need glasses too lol. Shack didn't start to turning in until the little downhill, which they both hit almost the same time, if you watch the demo they're going a pretty quick speed and you'd have to have the reaction of a ninja to know to slam on the brakes when he starts turning in. Also, in the demo Kwic was on the brakes every moment possible till impact. It certainly wasn't intentional. But yeah, that's just my two cents, everyone will think what they want to think. None of us would even be talking about this one little accident if someone hadn't decided to bring it up. I'm sure there are tons more accidents like this that happened in that race. Really, I think it's no big deal, just part of racing, stuff happens. Not sure why people think that calling someone out on little things like this is gonna make anything better. Actually yeah, I just realized how proving whose fault this is is absolutely pointless :D
My Stats
Discord: MxBrina#9694
jlv wrote:Team Motosport Honda's Brina made MX Simulator history as she became the first woman to take a win in a major series.
ShackAttack12
Posts: 3131
Joined: Fri May 09, 2008 1:51 am
Location: San Diego, CA

Re: 2011 SX Series by MotoOption Rd 11 - Thursday Night Mar 17

Post by ShackAttack12 »

First off, i'd like to make it clear that it's not winning that matters so much to me, its having clean races. I'd rather have a clean battle with guys and lose than lose because of things out of my control (getting hit, for example). I'm sure all of MXS feels this way.

By the way, you better be holding a fire extinguisher with a try-hard-to-make-you-look-smart-but-failed kind of post like that.

Holy shit wheels, you make me sound like a completely horrible and dirty rider. You make this long drawn out post with screenshots of me and label me as some sort of dirty rider........ I really can't believe you. I hope you are just trying to troll me, because quite honestly, i got a good laugh out of your post. So allow me to critique your critique.
wheels1758 wrote:Alright...hope you're ready. On the order of one Mr.ShackAttack12 vs. Mr.Kwic :

Shack, he said he's sorry, and I think you need to go take a look at the demo again. I was not there last night, but I did take the time to watch and analyze the incident in question. Here is my take.

This is the first jump of the rhythm section after Shack passed KWIC. As you can see, there are about 1.5 - 2 bike lengths between the two riders.

http://i481.photobucket.com/albums/rr17 ... trance.png

They both triple onto the tabletop, KWIC has gained a little on Shack.

http://i481.photobucket.com/albums/rr17 ... bletop.png

The last jump of the section, KWIC has carried a little more speed, but is still back.

http://i481.photobucket.com/albums/rr17 ... 3_exit.png

Different view of above jump. As you can see, Shack has started to turn in, closing off KWIC's line.

http://i481.photobucket.com/albums/rr17 ... tAngle.png

This is where Shack landed, at the base of the berm.

http://i481.photobucket.com/albums/rr17 ... Landed.png
You are saying that i "Closed Off Kwic's line". Why don't you go take a screenshot reel of my line through that corner every lap, and then come back and tell me i "closed off his line". Before you do it, let me warn you that you'll be wasting your damn time. I take the same line in that corner every lap. In fact, go analyze everyone's line through that corner and you will notice that the line i take is the common entry and exit for that corner.

wheels1758 wrote:Same angle as above picture, this time at the moment KWIC is landing.

http://i481.photobucket.com/albums/rr17 ... Landed.png

As you can probably guess, KWIC had no chance of stopping before he "blatenly punted" Shack. We shall now take a look at the entire section from above.
If you trace the line that Shack took, there is no doubt it carried over into KWIC's line. As they are taking off from the last single, into the corner, KWIC has very few options:
1. Take and immediate right turn and fly over the berm, maybe missing shack.
2. Turn down into the corner and try to stay on the inside.

As you can imagine, every racer on these forums would choose option 2. Who in their right mind is going to fly off track so that someone else can take their preferred line? And for Shack to say he was Chad Reed'ed in that turn, he'd have to go take a look at the video of Reed's pass. KWIC collided with Shack in the middle of the turn, not the exit.

Image

So, in my opinion, this incident was bound to happen and would most likely happen to anyone really. I know if you are the one getting knocked around, it will seem like the guy did it out of anger or rage, but I don't believe that is the case. I also don't think you, Shack, should tell a guy to go watch the demo, when you obviously have not analyzed it OBJECTIVELY!
Kwic had the whole downside of the landing to the step-off before the single to brake. Instead, he chose to keep his speed up, jump through the corner, and land at the base of the berm, knowing that i was infront of him and would be making the corner there. Check out the frames right before kwic hits the single and after he hits the single. Since we are talking about angles and trajectories, look how much his angle changes! :roll: :roll: :roll:

wheels1758 wrote:NOW: Shackattack12, I'd like to show you a couple things and possibly open your eyes into some ways to go faster and avoid the carnage that so often seems to find you(coincidence?).
I just found this absolutely hilarious. :lol:
wheels1758 wrote:This is the first rhythm section on the first lap. Shack was taken out in the first turn by a rider that clipped the back wheel of another and lost control...not much you can do there. But riding like you're all alone on your private track is not okay during a supercross main event. In this image, the surrounding riders are there at the time the first image was taken, they have been removed from the rest for clarity. As you can see though, there are riders around you. I'm sure you will argue that you turned in slightly in the middle to avoid a fallen rider (Jonesy). That is understandable, and if you would have been landed on there, theres not much you can do. But nearing the end of the section, you begin to turn down rapidly, eventually exiting the section at around 30 degrees from center. You did this so you could get the hot line through that next corner. This is all good when youre alone on the track. But when there are people around you, you can't do it! Of all the times you raged about people not holding a line, you yourself have some trouble as well, apparently.

Image
I don't understand how you can even say this was dirty and unclean riding. In that situation, the line i took was the perfect line to take to stay out of the carnage.You cut out the other riders as to make me look more like a dirty rider and to try to make your point more valid. I doubled in, noticed there were downed riders ahead, so i rolled the next, realized it was clear ahead so i double the next from the left side to the center of the track because there were downed riders on the left, and then rolled the next and hugged the inside to stay away from the carnage in the corner. I suppose you think i should have just rolled everything and waited for all the riders to get up off the ground. Sorry, but Nice try.

wheels1758 wrote:And for the final image. There are downed riders in the corner after the first(on the first lap) supercross triple. Again this is on the initial lap of the race. As we can see, you grab the brakes and hug the inside to avoid some downed riders. In this image, the honda rider was left in for a few frames to show how things can go wrong when you don't hold a line. You didn't actually collide, because he grabbed a handful and jumped over you. Watching the demo, you slip going off the face of the first jump and careen across the track out of control. But even before that, look at your line. you are a solid 35-40 degrees from the direction of the section. If you (1) are that far from center, you will most likely slide when you grab the throttle. and (2) are going slow around the corner, you should just roll the first jump and continue through the section. If you had gone single, step on, step off, single, you would have lost way less time that you really did. But you decided to go for a little bigger line, and look how it payed off. Even though there was no carnage here, you can clearly see that something could have happened. Imagine if someone else took that line in front of you. I can imagine you would not have been happy about it. So I really think you need to start backing it down, and the races will start to go a little more your way. It is ridiculous to hear a guy complaining about sketchy riders and lappers, when they are riding out there like the track belongs to them. Your riding style really reminds me of James Stewart. The dude is fast, but gets caught up in too much carnage because he is not about to back it down.

Image
LOL, this is another funny one. I suppose the better option to take would have been to join the downed riders in the berm. :roll: I can't even believe you posted this.

I know i'm not the only one who would of cut down the inside of the track in that situation. It was the most intelligent thing to do. There were 2 (or 3) downed riders in the corner, one guy trying to go around the outside of them (who i thought would crash too), so ofcourse i'm going to cut inside, where there is clean free track, and try to avoid all of it.

Exiting the corner i tried to double out, back end slid out coming up the face, and i sketched out. Luckily i saved it.
wheels1758 wrote:I have been caught up in some crashes with you in the past and yes, some of them were my fault. I realize I am a mediocre rider and you probably consider me sketchy. Problem is, a lot of times that we have gotten together it is because one of us cuts down a turn, as if to shut the other one off. If you're going to ride like that, you have to be ready to take some hits, and you have to accept the fact that everyone out there is going for it. Heck, if you know a guy is coming in hot, go wide...square it up...and watch him head straight over the berm. You are faster than most everyone on here, and you have the ability to pass people. If its going to be close, shut down and pass them in the next turn. I seem to remember someone saying that about the Chad Reed/James Stewart incident.

Can someone get me some fire retardent? I think I'm going to need it!
By the way, when I described KWIC cutting inside in chad reed fashion, i meant the way he cut down inside and aimed for the center of me.
ShackAttack12
| 2010 Supercross Champ | 2011 Supercross Champ | 2019 Supercross Champ |
MXJProductions
Posts: 3880
Joined: Fri Feb 05, 2010 1:26 pm
Team: MXJP
Location: Bushnell, Florida.

Re: 2011 SX Series by MotoOption Rd 11 - Thursday Night Mar 17

Post by MXJProductions »

Just wanna add something to my post, djd much like u saying stewie should have check up to pass him later, well shack could have done the same right. I mean it goes both ways. Shack is faster than kwic ( record shows ) so he could have just passed him later esp seeing as it qas only a few laps into the event...
Post Reply